TM Forum Community

Hello Jonathan,

we are implementing requirements where we are using the User Roles & Permissions API. We implemented the GET, POST and PATCH both permission and user role successfully.
However we miss the DELETE for both permission and user role in the yaml.

Is somebody from your team working on it or can you provide us the most recent yaml for the TMF 672?

Our stakeholder is planning to start using the API End of September this year..

Appreciate your quick feedback. Thanks!

Regards
Erlina

Hi Erlina
In v5 I think that we have DELETE operations for all the entities in TMF672. But please be aware that there have been major changes in the entities.
The initial tranche of v5 APIs is in the final stages of internal review, so there is a good chance that some of them will be released to public beta in the next several weeks. However I cannot give a firm commitment.
I can make an enquiry to see if we can release the TMF672 assets to you as-is, but I'm not promising anything.

Hello Jonathan,

we are implementing requirements where we are using the User Roles & Permissions API. We implemented the GET, POST and PATCH both permission and user role successfully.
However we miss the DELETE for both permission and user role in the yaml.

Is somebody from your team working on it or can you provide us the most recent yaml for the TMF 672?

Our stakeholder is planning to start using the API End of September this year..

Appreciate your quick feedback. Thanks!

Regards
Erlina

Hi John,

thank you for your feedback.
Several weeks sound like a major changes are being made. However, if major changes will be going to happen, then not only we as the API provider but our API Consumer must also adjust the API-changes.  Anyhow, it's crucial for us to provide our stakeholder with the 'DELETE' operation.
Appreciated for your enquiry for the releasing the TMF672.
Our plan is to implement until the end of June so that the Stakeholder can test it, but then we will have to wait and are looking forward to get the new version of the yaml soon (also without the pdf-doc).

Many thanks in advance!

Best Regards
Erlina

Hi Erlina
In v5 I think that we have DELETE operations for all the entities in TMF672. But please be aware that there have been major changes in the entities.
The initial tranche of v5 APIs is in the final stages of internal review, so there is a good chance that some of them will be released to public beta in the next several weeks. However I cannot give a firm commitment.
I can make an enquiry to see if we can release the TMF672 assets to you as-is, but I'm not promising anything.

Hello Jonathan,

we are implementing requirements where we are using the User Roles & Permissions API. We implemented the GET, POST and PATCH both permission and user role successfully.
However we miss the DELETE for both permission and user role in the yaml.

Is somebody from your team working on it or can you provide us the most recent yaml for the TMF 672?

Our stakeholder is planning to start using the API End of September this year..

Appreciate your quick feedback. Thanks!

Regards
Erlina

Hi Johnathan,

as we haven't received any update regarding the DELETE-Operation, as well as, I haven't found a working progress about it in the GitLab. and due to the fact that our stakeholder truly need this feature (delete/permission), I have created a delete operation to API by following the delete-design pattern of the current TMF-APIs.

Regards

Erlina

Hi John,

thank you for your feedback.
Several weeks sound like a major changes are being made. However, if major changes will be going to happen, then not only we as the API provider but our API Consumer must also adjust the API-changes.  Anyhow, it's crucial for us to provide our stakeholder with the 'DELETE' operation.
Appreciated for your enquiry for the releasing the TMF672.
Our plan is to implement until the end of June so that the Stakeholder can test it, but then we will have to wait and are looking forward to get the new version of the yaml soon (also without the pdf-doc).

Many thanks in advance!

Best Regards
Erlina

Hi Erlina
In v5 I think that we have DELETE operations for all the entities in TMF672. But please be aware that there have been major changes in the entities.
The initial tranche of v5 APIs is in the final stages of internal review, so there is a good chance that some of them will be released to public beta in the next several weeks. However I cannot give a firm commitment.
I can make an enquiry to see if we can release the TMF672 assets to you as-is, but I'm not promising anything.

Hello Jonathan,

we are implementing requirements where we are using the User Roles & Permissions API. We implemented the GET, POST and PATCH both permission and user role successfully.
However we miss the DELETE for both permission and user role in the yaml.

Is somebody from your team working on it or can you provide us the most recent yaml for the TMF 672?

Our stakeholder is planning to start using the API End of September this year..

Appreciate your quick feedback. Thanks!

Regards
Erlina

Erlina

The changes are being made in the private github repository that we use for Open API design, and tmf672 has a dedicated branch https://github.com/tmforum-rand/OAS_Open_API_And_Data_Model/tree/TMF672_User_Role_Permission

If you have access to this github you'll be able to see the DELETE operations defined for PermissionSet, PermissionSpec, and PermissionSpecSet in the API's rules file.

Hi Johnathan,

as we haven't received any update regarding the DELETE-Operation, as well as, I haven't found a working progress about it in the GitLab. and due to the fact that our stakeholder truly need this feature (delete/permission), I have created a delete operation to API by following the delete-design pattern of the current TMF-APIs.

Regards

Erlina

Hi John,

thank you for your feedback.
Several weeks sound like a major changes are being made. However, if major changes will be going to happen, then not only we as the API provider but our API Consumer must also adjust the API-changes.  Anyhow, it's crucial for us to provide our stakeholder with the 'DELETE' operation.
Appreciated for your enquiry for the releasing the TMF672.
Our plan is to implement until the end of June so that the Stakeholder can test it, but then we will have to wait and are looking forward to get the new version of the yaml soon (also without the pdf-doc).

Many thanks in advance!

Best Regards
Erlina

Hi Erlina
In v5 I think that we have DELETE operations for all the entities in TMF672. But please be aware that there have been major changes in the entities.
The initial tranche of v5 APIs is in the final stages of internal review, so there is a good chance that some of them will be released to public beta in the next several weeks. However I cannot give a firm commitment.
I can make an enquiry to see if we can release the TMF672 assets to you as-is, but I'm not promising anything.

Hello Jonathan,

we are implementing requirements where we are using the User Roles & Permissions API. We implemented the GET, POST and PATCH both permission and user role successfully.
However we miss the DELETE for both permission and user role in the yaml.

Is somebody from your team working on it or can you provide us the most recent yaml for the TMF 672?

Our stakeholder is planning to start using the API End of September this year..

Appreciate your quick feedback. Thanks!

Regards
Erlina

Hi Erlina
In v5 I think that we have DELETE operations for all the entities in TMF672. But please be aware that there have been major changes in the entities.
The initial tranche of v5 APIs is in the final stages of internal review, so there is a good chance that some of them will be released to public beta in the next several weeks. However I cannot give a firm commitment.
I can make an enquiry to see if we can release the TMF672 assets to you as-is, but I'm not promising anything.

Hello Jonathan,

we are implementing requirements where we are using the User Roles & Permissions API. We implemented the GET, POST and PATCH both permission and user role successfully.
However we miss the DELETE for both permission and user role in the yaml.

Is somebody from your team working on it or can you provide us the most recent yaml for the TMF 672?

Our stakeholder is planning to start using the API End of September this year..

Appreciate your quick feedback. Thanks!

Regards
Erlina

Hi Jonathan

Regarding the review of the v5 Roles & Permissions spec, it seems that the permissionSet resource is using a "user" field instead of "grantee".  Presumably the "granter" can assign permissions to other party/party roles including machines (for AN).

Thanks!

Hi Erlina
In v5 I think that we have DELETE operations for all the entities in TMF672. But please be aware that there have been major changes in the entities.
The initial tranche of v5 APIs is in the final stages of internal review, so there is a good chance that some of them will be released to public beta in the next several weeks. However I cannot give a firm commitment.
I can make an enquiry to see if we can release the TMF672 assets to you as-is, but I'm not promising anything.

Hello Jonathan,

we are implementing requirements where we are using the User Roles & Permissions API. We implemented the GET, POST and PATCH both permission and user role successfully.
However we miss the DELETE for both permission and user role in the yaml.

Is somebody from your team working on it or can you provide us the most recent yaml for the TMF 672?

Our stakeholder is planning to start using the API End of September this year..

Appreciate your quick feedback. Thanks!

Regards
Erlina

Hi Dan

Machines are not party/party roles. We plan to add resource/resource roles as receivers of permissions, to allow for use cases such as ODA components or home gateways needing rights. If you have access to the project jira repository feel free to take a look: https://projects.tmforum.org/jira/browse/AP-4407

------------------------------
Jonathan Goldberg
Amdocs Management Limited
Any opinions and statements made by me on this forum are purely personal, and do not necessarily reflect the position of the TM Forum or my employer.

Original Message:
Sent: May 25, 2023 23:14
From: Dan d'Albuquerque
Subject: TMF672_UserRoles & Permissions API- missing DELETE operation

Hi Jonathan

Regarding the review of the v5 Roles & Permissions spec, it seems that the permissionSet resource is using a "user" field instead of "grantee".  Presumably the "granter" can assign permissions to other party/party roles including machines (for AN).

Thanks!

------------------------------
Dan d'Albuquerque
TO BE VERIFIED

Original Message:
Sent: May 23, 2023 15:26
From: Jonathan Goldberg
Subject: TMF672_UserRoles & Permissions API- missing DELETE operation

Hi Erlina
In v5 I think that we have DELETE operations for all the entities in TMF672. But please be aware that there have been major changes in the entities.
The initial tranche of v5 APIs is in the final stages of internal review, so there is a good chance that some of them will be released to public beta in the next several weeks. However I cannot give a firm commitment.
I can make an enquiry to see if we can release the TMF672 assets to you as-is, but I'm not promising anything.

------------------------------
Jonathan Goldberg
Amdocs Management Limited
Any opinions and statements made by me on this forum are purely personal, and do not necessarily reflect the position of the TM Forum or my employer.

Original Message:
Sent: May 23, 2023 09:16
From: Erlina Hennies
Subject: TMF672_UserRoles & Permissions API- missing DELETE operation

Hello Jonathan,

we are implementing requirements where we are using the User Roles & Permissions API. We implemented the GET, POST and PATCH both permission and user role successfully.
However we miss the DELETE for both permission and user role in the yaml.

Is somebody from your team working on it or can you provide us the most recent yaml for the TMF 672?

Our stakeholder is planning to start using the API End of September this year..

Appreciate your quick feedback. Thanks!

Regards
Erlina

#General

------------------------------
Erlina Hennies
Deutsche Telekom AG
------------------------------

Thanks Jonathan.
Actually I was referring to the AIops specs that referred to Machine being a Party.  Nonetheless, do you still plan to refer to the consumer of the permission as a user?
PS: Just noticed that you have defined a user as the receiver of the permission at the top of the TMF672 API spec.  Just feels a bit strange when the receiver of the permission could be an administrator role and not the end-user of the product/resource itself.
Thanks! 

------------------------------
Dan d'Albuquerque
TO BE VERIFIED

Original Message:
Sent: May 28, 2023 02:56
From: Jonathan Goldberg
Subject: TMF672_UserRoles & Permissions API- missing DELETE operation

Hi Dan

Machines are not party/party roles. We plan to add resource/resource roles as receivers of permissions, to allow for use cases such as ODA components or home gateways needing rights. If you have access to the project jira repository feel free to take a look: https://projects.tmforum.org/jira/browse/AP-4407

------------------------------
Jonathan Goldberg
Amdocs Management Limited
Any opinions and statements made by me on this forum are purely personal, and do not necessarily reflect the position of the TM Forum or my employer.

Original Message:
Sent: May 25, 2023 23:14
From: Dan d'Albuquerque
Subject: TMF672_UserRoles & Permissions API- missing DELETE operation

Hi Jonathan

Regarding the review of the v5 Roles & Permissions spec, it seems that the permissionSet resource is using a "user" field instead of "grantee".  Presumably the "granter" can assign permissions to other party/party roles including machines (for AN).

Thanks!

------------------------------
Dan d'Albuquerque
TO BE VERIFIED

Original Message:
Sent: May 23, 2023 15:26
From: Jonathan Goldberg
Subject: TMF672_UserRoles & Permissions API- missing DELETE operation

Hi Erlina
In v5 I think that we have DELETE operations for all the entities in TMF672. But please be aware that there have been major changes in the entities.
The initial tranche of v5 APIs is in the final stages of internal review, so there is a good chance that some of them will be released to public beta in the next several weeks. However I cannot give a firm commitment.
I can make an enquiry to see if we can release the TMF672 assets to you as-is, but I'm not promising anything.

------------------------------
Jonathan Goldberg
Amdocs Management Limited
Any opinions and statements made by me on this forum are purely personal, and do not necessarily reflect the position of the TM Forum or my employer.

Original Message:
Sent: May 23, 2023 09:16
From: Erlina Hennies
Subject: TMF672_UserRoles & Permissions API- missing DELETE operation

Hello Jonathan,

we are implementing requirements where we are using the User Roles & Permissions API. We implemented the GET, POST and PATCH both permission and user role successfully.
However we miss the DELETE for both permission and user role in the yaml.

Is somebody from your team working on it or can you provide us the most recent yaml for the TMF 672?

Our stakeholder is planning to start using the API End of September this year..

Appreciate your quick feedback. Thanks!

Regards
Erlina

#General

------------------------------
Erlina Hennies
Deutsche Telekom AG
------------------------------

Hi Erlina
In v5 I think that we have DELETE operations for all the entities in TMF672. But please be aware that there have been major changes in the entities.
The initial tranche of v5 APIs is in the final stages of internal review, so there is a good chance that some of them will be released to public beta in the next several weeks. However I cannot give a firm commitment.
I can make an enquiry to see if we can release the TMF672 assets to you as-is, but I'm not promising anything.

Hello Jonathan,

we are implementing requirements where we are using the User Roles & Permissions API. We implemented the GET, POST and PATCH both permission and user role successfully.
However we miss the DELETE for both permission and user role in the yaml.

Is somebody from your team working on it or can you provide us the most recent yaml for the TMF 672?

Our stakeholder is planning to start using the API End of September this year..

Appreciate your quick feedback. Thanks!

Regards
Erlina

Hi Jonathan!

Where can I currently view information about the TMF672 v5 API?
Has the SID changed due to new changes that came in v5 API?
Is there any information when the TMF672 v5 API is planned to be published https://www.tmforum.org/oda/open-apis/table?

Thanks!

Best Regards
Denis

Hi Erlina
In v5 I think that we have DELETE operations for all the entities in TMF672. But please be aware that there have been major changes in the entities.
The initial tranche of v5 APIs is in the final stages of internal review, so there is a good chance that some of them will be released to public beta in the next several weeks. However I cannot give a firm commitment.
I can make an enquiry to see if we can release the TMF672 assets to you as-is, but I'm not promising anything.

Hello Jonathan,

we are implementing requirements where we are using the User Roles & Permissions API. We implemented the GET, POST and PATCH both permission and user role successfully.
However we miss the DELETE for both permission and user role in the yaml.

Is somebody from your team working on it or can you provide us the most recent yaml for the TMF 672?

Our stakeholder is planning to start using the API End of September this year..

Appreciate your quick feedback. Thanks!

Regards
Erlina

Hi Denis

Waiting for final review by Open API chief architect.

The SID was already updated, I think already in 22.5, to reflect the new permissions model - what you see in the SID is similar to what you'll see in the Open API model for TMF672, with a few differences due to the different model philosophies between SID and Open API.

Hope it helps

Hi Jonathan!

Where can I currently view information about the TMF672 v5 API?
Has the SID changed due to new changes that came in v5 API?
Is there any information when the TMF672 v5 API is planned to be published https://www.tmforum.org/oda/open-apis/table?

Thanks!

Best Regards
Denis

Hi Erlina
In v5 I think that we have DELETE operations for all the entities in TMF672. But please be aware that there have been major changes in the entities.
The initial tranche of v5 APIs is in the final stages of internal review, so there is a good chance that some of them will be released to public beta in the next several weeks. However I cannot give a firm commitment.
I can make an enquiry to see if we can release the TMF672 assets to you as-is, but I'm not promising anything.

Hello Jonathan,

we are implementing requirements where we are using the User Roles & Permissions API. We implemented the GET, POST and PATCH both permission and user role successfully.
However we miss the DELETE for both permission and user role in the yaml.

Is somebody from your team working on it or can you provide us the most recent yaml for the TMF 672?

Our stakeholder is planning to start using the API End of September this year..

Appreciate your quick feedback. Thanks!

Regards
Erlina

Hi Jonathan

Has the final review been completed?  Where would I be able to find the latest TMF672 v5 OAS?  I could not find it in the production or pre-prod area of the TM Forum OpenAPI tables page.

Thanks

Hi Denis

Waiting for final review by Open API chief architect.

The SID was already updated, I think already in 22.5, to reflect the new permissions model - what you see in the SID is similar to what you'll see in the Open API model for TMF672, with a few differences due to the different model philosophies between SID and Open API.

Hope it helps

Hi Jonathan!

Where can I currently view information about the TMF672 v5 API?
Has the SID changed due to new changes that came in v5 API?
Is there any information when the TMF672 v5 API is planned to be published https://www.tmforum.org/oda/open-apis/table?

Thanks!

Best Regards
Denis

Hi Erlina
In v5 I think that we have DELETE operations for all the entities in TMF672. But please be aware that there have been major changes in the entities.
The initial tranche of v5 APIs is in the final stages of internal review, so there is a good chance that some of them will be released to public beta in the next several weeks. However I cannot give a firm commitment.
I can make an enquiry to see if we can release the TMF672 assets to you as-is, but I'm not promising anything.

Hello Jonathan,

we are implementing requirements where we are using the User Roles & Permissions API. We implemented the GET, POST and PATCH both permission and user role successfully.
However we miss the DELETE for both permission and user role in the yaml.

Is somebody from your team working on it or can you provide us the most recent yaml for the TMF 672?

Our stakeholder is planning to start using the API End of September this year..

Appreciate your quick feedback. Thanks!

Regards
Erlina

I'm also still waiting for review to close, sorry.

Hi Jonathan

Has the final review been completed?  Where would I be able to find the latest TMF672 v5 OAS?  I could not find it in the production or pre-prod area of the TM Forum OpenAPI tables page.

Thanks

Hi Denis

Waiting for final review by Open API chief architect.

The SID was already updated, I think already in 22.5, to reflect the new permissions model - what you see in the SID is similar to what you'll see in the Open API model for TMF672, with a few differences due to the different model philosophies between SID and Open API.

Hope it helps

Hi Jonathan!

Where can I currently view information about the TMF672 v5 API?
Has the SID changed due to new changes that came in v5 API?
Is there any information when the TMF672 v5 API is planned to be published https://www.tmforum.org/oda/open-apis/table?

Thanks!

Best Regards
Denis

Hi Erlina
In v5 I think that we have DELETE operations for all the entities in TMF672. But please be aware that there have been major changes in the entities.
The initial tranche of v5 APIs is in the final stages of internal review, so there is a good chance that some of them will be released to public beta in the next several weeks. However I cannot give a firm commitment.
I can make an enquiry to see if we can release the TMF672 assets to you as-is, but I'm not promising anything.

Hello Jonathan,

we are implementing requirements where we are using the User Roles & Permissions API. We implemented the GET, POST and PATCH both permission and user role successfully.
However we miss the DELETE for both permission and user role in the yaml.

Is somebody from your team working on it or can you provide us the most recent yaml for the TMF 672?

Our stakeholder is planning to start using the API End of September this year..

Appreciate your quick feedback. Thanks!

Regards
Erlina

Hi Jonathan,

It's been a few months since any update on this.

Are we any closer to the review being finished? Is there any guess on when that may happen.

Thanks

I'm also still waiting for review to close, sorry.

Hi Jonathan

Has the final review been completed?  Where would I be able to find the latest TMF672 v5 OAS?  I could not find it in the production or pre-prod area of the TM Forum OpenAPI tables page.

Thanks

Hi Denis

Waiting for final review by Open API chief architect.

The SID was already updated, I think already in 22.5, to reflect the new permissions model - what you see in the SID is similar to what you'll see in the Open API model for TMF672, with a few differences due to the different model philosophies between SID and Open API.

Hope it helps

Hi Jonathan!

Where can I currently view information about the TMF672 v5 API?
Has the SID changed due to new changes that came in v5 API?
Is there any information when the TMF672 v5 API is planned to be published https://www.tmforum.org/oda/open-apis/table?

Thanks!

Best Regards
Denis

Hi Erlina
In v5 I think that we have DELETE operations for all the entities in TMF672. But please be aware that there have been major changes in the entities.
The initial tranche of v5 APIs is in the final stages of internal review, so there is a good chance that some of them will be released to public beta in the next several weeks. However I cannot give a firm commitment.
I can make an enquiry to see if we can release the TMF672 assets to you as-is, but I'm not promising anything.

Hello Jonathan,

we are implementing requirements where we are using the User Roles & Permissions API. We implemented the GET, POST and PATCH both permission and user role successfully.
However we miss the DELETE for both permission and user role in the yaml.

Is somebody from your team working on it or can you provide us the most recent yaml for the TMF 672?

Our stakeholder is planning to start using the API End of September this year..

Appreciate your quick feedback. Thanks!

Regards
Erlina